Quote:
Originally Posted by lowcarbUgh
There are other foods that you can enjoy that I want to work back into my diet. Should I not have that opportunity? I'm never going to make my insulin dependency any better - ever! I'm eating so few carbs that I'm bolusing 2-3 units a meal and I probably have less circulating insulin and much less insulin resistance than you. I just don't make any.
|
That is the limitation of Bernstein. Don't get me wrong, I've been a Bernstein fan for *years* and have given his book as gifts many times.
But he is too dogmatic.
I bought his newer book when I got home from the hospital because his older book had instructions for insulins that are no longer available. However... his dosing rules assume you eat the same amount of protein and carb for breakfast at the same time every day, ditto for lunch and dinner.
I'm just not that consistent. Some days I'm hungry, some days I'm not - I don't eat the same every day. One day I'll eat 800 calories and the next eat 2000. I average 1400-1600, but there's lots of variation.
Some nights I stay up late and sleep in the next day. Some times I take a road trip to visit family and have to eat out and don't know the *exact* carb and protein content of my meals.
My life isn't regimented enough to *strictly* follow his system.
Bernstein's system is how I adjust my Sweetarts for hypos, and how I figured my corrective bolus and how I adjusted my basal. But I had to go elsewhere to figure out how to adjust bolus to match meals.
So... I looked around and read books on pumping insulin. I don't have a pump, and don't want one yet, but... those systems are designed to learn to control bg with a flexible life. Reading that stuff is part of how I learned to adjust my bolus doses (though it's addressed primarily to high-carbing T1s).
I also *do* think Bernstein's diet is too restrictive... for *me*. I'm not willing to never eat fruit, never eat cottage cheese, etc.
But there is a place in between going as strict as he does and just eating whatever. I have several other diabetics in my family and all of them eat anything and just ignore their diabetes. Frankly, the ADA diet would be a *big* improvement for them.
I eat *way* better than that even if it's not ideal. Overall, people have to develop a diet that is livable for them. This is not for the short term for weight loss, but for the long term to avoid blindness, heart attacks, kidney disease, amputation. You *have* to stick to it because it's too important to screw it up!
For me, I consider cottage cheese and yogurt staples... anytime I need to eat and don't have leftovers, they're there as fast protein sources.
I eat lower-sugar fruits too - a cup of melon or berries, a kiwi, half a pomegranate, and at least once each summer I eat an entire peach. Never at breakfast, always with a meal including lots of protein and fat, and not more than once a day. That works for me cause I'm just not going to live forever without fruit.
So... I need to be able to adjust my insulin for what I can really live with, not for an "ideal" diet that I don't stick to.
There's a post about how I figured out my "rules" for bolus dosing here:
http://groups.google.com/group/alt....931a05a37aae0b2
The other thing is... Bernstein doesn't tell you what to do when you "cheat." I've been low-carbing for over a decade, and for me, cheats are going to happen. I know this. There are foods I can live without 99% of the time, but there's always that 1% of the time that I give in to temptation and I want to minimize the bg excursions. For me, I use the same "rules" for dosing when I eat off plan, knowing my postprandials will be out of range, and then do a corrective bolus at the next meal. This limits how bad my numbers are over a cheat. I also only cheat one meal a month. I learned this even before insulin, I can "recover" from one meal in a day, but if I cheat for an entire day, it takes 2-3 days to recover. So one meal once a month is my limit and my other "rule" for cheating is... I *must* test. I need to *see* how bad each cheat is to decide which ones are "worth it."